How Culture Shapes the Climate Change Debate Review

• Home
• My Books

Open Preview

See a Problem?

We'd love your aid. Permit us know what's wrong with this preview of How Culture Shapes the Climatic change Debate by Andrew J. Hoffman.

Thanks for telling us almost the problem.

Friend Reviews

To run into what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

Be the first to ask a question about How Civilization Shapes the Climate Change Fence

Community Reviews

 · 223 ratings  · 21 reviews

Start your review of How Civilisation Shapes the Climate change Debate

Apr 19, 2015 Jim Rossi rated it really liked information technology

This is a actually concise - under 100 pages, not including end matter - and informative book about the social values that lie behind the climatic change debate. I promise that it help cools downwardly the polarizing dogma and rhetoric on all sides. Hoffman has a scrap more "faith" in the integrity of imperfect scientific institutions than I practice, and he also doesn't fully convey that it's no longer Climate Change vs. Big Business organization; climate change IS big business: $24 billion/year just in regime-funded resea This is a really concise - under 100 pages, non including cease thing - and informative book most the social values that lie behind the climate change debate. I hope that information technology help cools downward the polarizing dogma and rhetoric on all sides. Hoffman has a bit more "faith" in the integrity of imperfect scientific institutions than I exercise, and he also doesn't fully convey that it'south no longer Climate Modify vs. Big Business organisation; climate change IS big business: $24 billion/yr just in regime-funded research, meted out to researchers and PhD students in an unsustainable, brutal job market place, whose career prospects depend upon getting that grant money. Simply overall, a very fine short study. ...more

Dec 06, 2018 Rebecca rated information technology did not like it

This book doesn't have that much crucial data in it. Information technology reminds you that many people don't believe climate change is existent, that the GOP has promoted this lack of belief, and argues that haranguing people or trying to "beat" them in arguments doesn't change their minds. That's all fine, merely non big news. One of the things the author argues is that people demand to trust the sources that are used in order to be persuaded, and for this reason, he suggests citing conservatives who believe clima This book doesn't have that much crucial information in information technology. Information technology reminds you that many people don't believe climatic change is existent, that the GOP has promoted this lack of belief, and argues that haranguing people or trying to "shell" them in arguments doesn't change their minds. That's all fine, but not big news. I of the things the author argues is that people need to trust the sources that are used in club to exist persuaded, and for this reason, he suggests citing conservatives who believe climate scientific discipline is real if you are trying to argue with conservatives. I guess this general signal about trustworthy sources is true, because when the writer concluded a chapter on this very point with a long quotation from Richard Nixon on leadership, I decided the author was not very politically acute. He later makes arguments about abolitionism (too radical! turned off Lincoln!) that also don't signal a wealth of historical knowledge or agreement of how social movements create change. ...more than

May 21, 2015 Thomas Cook rated it it was astonishing

Do yous avoid talking about climate change? This has become a polarizing topic, and some of the states avoid raising it to avoid debate, offending others, or from coming off like Al Gore. Other people I know don't talk virtually it because they have serious questions, or legitimate concerns about proposed solutions. This is too bad, as we all could benefit from discussing this of import topic. This book helps put the climate change controversy into both a social science and historical context. Chiefly, i Do you lot avert talking about climate change? This has become a polarizing topic, and some of usa avoid raising it to avert debate, offending others, or from coming off similar Al Gore. Other people I know don't talk nearly it because they have serious questions, or legitimate concerns about proposed solutions. This is too bad, as nosotros all could benefit from discussing this of import topic. This volume helps put the climate change controversy into both a social science and historical context. Chiefly, it gives helpful hints about how to talk about the issue in a effective style. Of course, listening always helps, and the volume helps you to sympathise others perspective on the result. I have met the author, Andy Hoffman, and he brings a smart sensibility and lots of experience to this issue. The book is accessible, well-written, not overly bookish, and a quick/curt read. I recommend information technology to anyone with an interest in the effect. ...more

Nov 16, 2019 Philippa rated it information technology was amazing

Fantastic examination well-nigh how climate alter is not just an consequence of science but of cultural belief systems and values. Gives you lot conversational tools on how to tackle this chat with people from all beliefs in a fashion that will have the most efficacy.

Aug 26, 2019 Kate rated it liked information technology

Finally done with the smith reads book! I can't wait to discuss it more than with others, simply overall I enjoyed it. Finally done with the smith reads book! I can't wait to talk over it more with others, but overall I enjoyed it. ...more

December 22, 2015 Betsy D rated information technology it was amazing

Hoffman presents some research-based, helpful answers to a long-standing question of mine: how do climatic change contrarians call up about the issue, and how can we reach them? He explains their values--largely economic--and resistances, and fears, without lumping all in one pile.
I don't know whether I can speak about helpful climate actions in terms of economic science, since those are far from my motivations, but many are moved by health and pollution concerns, too, which could work better for me.
And, Hoffman presents some research-based, helpful answers to a long-standing question of mine: how do climate change contrarians recollect about the issue, and how tin we reach them? He explains their values--largely economic--and resistances, and fears, without lumping all in one pile.
I don't know whether I can speak most helpful climate actions in terms of economic science, since those are far from my motivations, but many are moved by health and pollution concerns, likewise, which could work amend for me.
And, of course, don't put people on the defensive.
A brusk little book, well worth reading. ...more

Jul 26, 2019 Jeanne rated it liked it

I take mixed feelings nearly this book. I did similar the mode it was laid out and the look at the issue from a cultural perspective. Even so, it already feels a bit dated. The book came out before the Paris Climate Accords (and the subsequent US withdrawal) which really changed the conversation. Too, the predictions accept gotten much more dire and immediate, and I think overall there is a lot more than buy in. Perhaps that is a sign that what is outlined here worked, at to the lowest degree on a public opinion level. East I have mixed feelings about this book. I did like the mode information technology was laid out and the await at the issue from a cultural perspective. However, information technology already feels a scrap dated. The book came out before the Paris Climate Accords (and the subsequent US withdrawal) which really changed the conversation. Also, the predictions accept gotten much more dire and firsthand, and I think overall there is a lot more than buy in. Perhaps that is a sign that what is outlined here worked, at to the lowest degree on a public opinion level. Even if not all leaders are on board, it feels like more of the public has come to a consensus on the issue.

Also, the political landscape has shifted so drastically I merely don't feel like some of the same rules utilize. A lot of his arguments middle on reason, and the by few years have shown that reason, logic, and facts don't always take a identify in our discourse. I agree with his primary idea that you lot have to empathize the political landscape to make your arguments, but the mural has inverse so rapidly so fast that his suggestions feel almost quaint.

I read this because it was the summertime reading volume for my alma affair, and I call back it was an odd choice. The concept is great in theory (and better by far than the other climate change volume they did a few years dorsum), just information technology'due south dated already and I feel like they could have found something stronger for such a gimmicky topic. Likewise the ending pretty much gave the message that if you lot tin't reasonably talk someone to the centre of the result you shouldn't bother, which sat poorly with me. The campus has had a lot of educatee activism which the administration has not handled well, and this reads to me as a super passive aggressive statement to the new students.

I also wonder who the intended audience is for this. It was accessible to me, merely I also have ii college degrees and a basic familiarity with the text. I'm curious to know if incoming students felt similar they could appoint with the material at all.

...more

Nov 25, 2016 Leah rated it really liked it

A solid, succinct summary of what causes people to believe or doubt climate science (hint: not scientific arguments). This volume presents unlike lenses through which people look at the world, backed by studies, and examines how to cater to these lenses and effectively change minds. These tactics could be used beyond debates about climate change as well. I do wish at that place were more example conversations in the book, since the list of questions to inquire oneself about where a person is coming from exist A solid, succinct summary of what causes people to believe or doubt climate science (hint: not scientific arguments). This book presents different lenses through which people look at the earth, backed past studies, and examines how to cater to these lenses and effectively change minds. These tactics could be used across debates almost climate change as well. I practice wish in that location were more example conversations in the book, since the list of questions to ask oneself about where a person is coming from before engaging them in discussion on climate change is a long one. The volume's purported aim is to provide citizens with tools for finer shifting the dialogue and leading to climate action, so I would have liked a bit more in the manner of persuasive statements given their different lenses and standpoints. Yet, a very worthwhile read that presents strategies that I will effort to utilize to outcome modify. ...more

A very important volume. It is not mainly about climatic change, but about how we make up our mind about it. It partly deals with the topic of scholarly consensus. I wish it could take gone even more securely into that. Personally I wonder if the perception that scholarly consensus is a kind of conspiracy may exist the most unsafe conspiracy theory of our time, since it makes political leaders pull in the wrong management in a very critical fourth dimension of history.

Someone should write a popular scientific discipline book o

A very important volume. It is not mainly about climate change, but almost how nosotros make up our mind about it. It partly deals with the topic of scholarly consensus. I wish information technology could accept gone even more deeply into that. Personally I wonder if the perception that scholarly consensus is a kind of conspiracy may be the most dangerous conspiracy theory of our time, since it makes political leaders pull in the wrong direction in a very disquisitional time of history.

Someone should write a popular science book on what is involved in the concept of scholarly consensus. If it had been well written for usa ordinary people, it would do a lot of good. If anyone can guide me to such literature, I would be very grateful!

...more

Svinabra, intressant(!!!) och nyttig.
Fina analyser kring hur homo kan förändra majoritetens synsätt på världen, människans plats och ansvar på planeten och den globala uppvärmningen.

"More science, though important, will not by itself change people's minds and create the collective will to act. (...) The debate over climate change is not virtually greenhouse gases and climate models lone. Information technology is about the competing world views and cultural beliefs of people who must accept the science, even when information technology c

Svinabra, intressant(!!!) och nyttig.
Fina analyser kring hur homo kan förändra majoritetens synsätt på världen, människans plats och ansvar på planeten och den globala uppvärmningen.

"More science, though important, will not past itself alter people'southward minds and create the collective volition to deed. (...) The debate over climate modify is not almost greenhouse gases and climate models alone. It is well-nigh the competing earth views and cultural beliefs of people who must accept the scientific discipline, even when it challenges those beliefs"

Värt att notera att den skrevs 2014 och en del har hänt sen dess på området

...more

May 21, 2020 Quinn Collard rated it really liked it

This book argues that the schism in American attitudes about climatic change is attributable to cultural attitudes and values and then working within this context will be more effective at getting people to be willing to practice something well-nigh it than but throwing scientific data at them. I think this makes sense and probably applies to many other divisive issues as well, so the book gave me a lot to think about, and I appreciated the clear, accessible language the author used to explain complex topic This book argues that the schism in American attitudes about climate change is attributable to cultural attitudes and values and then working within this context will exist more effective at getting people to exist willing to exercise something about it than just throwing scientific data at them. I recall this makes sense and probably applies to many other divisive issues as well, so the book gave me a lot to call back about, and I appreciated the articulate, accessible linguistic communication the writer used to explain complex topics. ...more

Outset of all, permit me say that this book is only ninety pages (the remaining thirty are notes.) That'due south important because otherwise you might not want to read it. :-) But it's quick, well-written and packed with information.

This book is not nigh proving climate modify. It's about WHY there is such a carve up in public opinion near climate change and HOW we can try to shrink that divide. The problems dividing united states are non conflicting scientific information, they are about alien values and cultur

First of all, allow me say that this book is only ninety pages (the remaining thirty are notes.) That's important considering otherwise you might not want to read it. :-) But it's quick, well-written and packed with information.

This volume is non about proving climatic change. It's about WHY there is such a separate in public stance about climate modify and HOW we can endeavour to compress that divide. The issues dividing u.s.a. are not alien scientific information, they are about conflicting values and cultures.

My book social club read it and my church "green group" volition be reading it. Highly recommended.

...more

Apr 02, 2018 Skunk rated it information technology was amazing

This was surprisingly skilful for a class required materials. This book is about the cultural separate of climatic change and why at that place is a separate. I establish it to be enlightening as a hereafter environmental scientist. This book outlines the issue and makes it easier to empathise why people are torn over climate change. It volition be a useful tool for my scientific communication with the public.

Aug 15, 2019 C rated it it was astonishing

An excellent and informative read that I'd highly recommend to everyone! How Culture Shapes the Climate Change Debate isn't just nigh climate change; information technology applies to gun command, abortion, and practically any other polarizing electric current upshot you can think of. This book serves as a buoy of low-cal in our globe that seems to be saturated by binary thinking and bipartisan politics.

An first-class digest on the steps needed to bring the Republican party back into the fold of science. I will add steps is a misnomer but I can't remember of a ameliorate way to put it. In any instance this volume is a mode to think about how we every bit an entire society can move forrad even with our disagreements. An excellent digest on the steps needed to bring the Republican party back into the fold of science. I will add steps is a misnomer just I can't think of a better mode to put it. In any case this book is a way to think nigh how we as an entire social club can motility forward even with our disagreements. ...more

Sep 25, 2019 Sophia rated it did not similar it

Boring and pretentious. Insists victims must accept politically neutral friendships. White man nonsense.

Sep 22, 2017 Chuck McGrady rated information technology information technology was amazing

A thought-provoking book whose lessons extend beyond the subject of climate change.

Mar 03, 2022 Mckinley rated information technology really liked it

A look at climate change within a framework of biases and perspectives.
4 forms of distrust : messenger, procedure, message, solution

An interesting book that gets a lot right. Nice to see something that moves beyond emotional satisfaction to understanding what really moves people. Interesting to come across Jonathan Haidt'south work cited. An interesting volume that gets a lot right. Nice to see something that moves across emotional satisfaction to understanding what really moves people. Interesting to come across Jonathan Haidt's work cited. ...more

Related Articles

Spring is finally here, give thanks the gods. That was a crude winter.   To gloat the twelvemonth'southward greenest flavor, we've gathered here the best new...

Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads business relationship.

butlerinteepty.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23604092-how-culture-shapes-the-climate-change-debate

Share this post